North Shore Tutors · HSC English Standard · Module B · 2027–2030

The Good Teachers: HSC Analysis

Carol Ann Duffy · Poem

An imagined visit to school revives both the appeal of learning and the discomfort of being appraised.

Context and purpose

The poem puts the title’s apparent approval under pressure by portraying intellectual care and cruelty in the same authority.

Form and macro techniques

Retrospective second person and present tense create immediacy. Quick portraits shift from nostalgia to appraisal, before school judgement carries into adult life.

Theme 1: Nostalgia and judgement

Central argument: Returning to school also means returning to the experience of being measured.

QuotationTechniqueAnalysis
“You run round the back to be in it again”Second-person present tenseThe physical movement gives the remembered past a temporary presence.
“those virtuous women size you up from the front row”Evaluative epithetVirtuous can be admiring or ironic, but size you up makes the adult gaze sound uncomfortably appraising.

Theme 2: Competing qualities and internalised expectations

Central argument: Duffy refuses an easy division between good and bad teachers.

QuotationTechniqueAnalysis
“Her kind intelligent green eye. Her cruel blue one.”Antithesis and colour contrastCare and cruelty occupy the same face rather than separate portraits.
“You could do better. But there’s the wall you climb”Direct speech and metaphorThe remembered rebuke becomes an image of an obstacle the adult must confront.

Model analytical paragraph

Practice questions

  • How does the title complicate the judgement it appears to offer?
  • Compare the experience of returning to school here with In Mrs Tilscher’s Class.

Other poems in this selection