North Shore Tutors · HSC English Standard · Module B · 2027–2030

Stealing: HSC Analysis

Carol Ann Duffy · Poem

An unnamed thief recalls stealing a snowman. The confession exposes a longing for company that the speaker tries to satisfy through control.

Context and purpose

First published in Selling Manhattan (1987), the poem separates the speaker’s self-justifying account from Duffy’s perspective. Humour makes the voice engaging without making its cruelty excusable.

Form and macro techniques

A dramatic monologue stages an unanswered conversation. The opening confession gives way to the failed reconstruction of the snowman and an unresolved challenge to the listener.

Theme 1: Isolation and imagined companionship

Central argument: The speaker wants a companion who cannot refuse or demand anything.

QuotationTechniqueAnalysis
“The most unusual thing I ever stole? A snowman.”Bathos and self-questioningThe bizarre prize deflates the boast and draws attention to the speaker’s need for an audience.
“He looked magnificent; a tall, white mute”PersonificationThe admiration depends on the figure’s inability to speak, so the imagined intimacy does not allow reciprocity.

Theme 2: Control and defensive self-justification

Central argument: The thief presents taking as freedom but relies on controlling reactions.

QuotationTechniqueAnalysis
“Better off dead than giving in, not taking what you want.”MaximThe false choice between taking and giving in turns a personal defence into a purported rule for living.
“You don’t understand a word I’m saying, do you?”Accusatory direct addressThe speaker blames the listener’s incomprehension but does not leave room for an answer.

Model analytical paragraph

Practice questions

  • To what extent does Duffy invite sympathy for the speaker without excusing the theft?
  • Compare the snowman with a domestic object in Mrs Midas. How does possessing it undo its value?

Other poems in this selection