North Shore Tutors · HSC English Advanced · Module A · 2027–2030

A Poison Tree

The poem describes two different ways of living with anger. What begins as a choice about speaking ends as a carefully nurtured trap, narrated by a speaker who shows little sign of regret.

Contents

Form, voice and narrative development

Four compact quatrains with insistent rhymes make a sinister process easy to recite. The first stanza tests two versions of the same situation; the next two replace social exchange with cultivation; the last moves from night-time trespass to discovery in daylight. The speaker alone controls the account.

↑ Back to contents

The difference between feeling and making

Anger is not automatically poisonous: one declared quarrel ends. It is the maintenance of secrecy that turns a feeling into a project. The agrarian metaphor gives ordinary gestures of care an inverted purpose. Smiling can conceal hostility, and the apparent health of the tree is evidence of the speaker’s successful deception.

↑ Back to contents

A conclusion that refuses remorse

Possession matters: it is the speaker’s garden and the enemy’s entry, but the garden has been cultivated to attract him. The final outstretched figure, read as dead, is reported without confession of a direct physical strike. The allocation of blame matters more than whether Blake supplies a forensic explanation.

↑ Back to contents

Quotation analysis

Textual evidenceLocationTechniqueAnalysis and effect
“I told my wrath, my wrath did end.”Stanza 1Repetition and causal juxtapositionExpressing the emotion allows it to stop; repeated wrath moves from object of speech to subject of a completed action.
“I was angry with my foe:”Stanza 1Antithesis with the friendAlmost identical syntax tests a different relationship and outcome rather than assuming a different original emotion.
“And I sunned it with smiles,”Stanza 2Cultivation metaphor and alliterationThe apparent kindness of the gesture sustains the hidden hostility instead of disarming it.
“And into my garden stole,”Stanza 4Possessive pronoun and loaded verbThe foe certainly enters, but the speaker’s control of the setting complicates the account of trespass.
“My foe outstretchd beneath the tree.”Final lineStark visual image and ironic closureThe position of the body under the thing cultivated measures the cost of the speaker’s apparent victory.

↑ Back to contents

Model analytical paragraph

Blake’s opening parallels insist that the speaker does not become violent merely by feeling anger. Repetition in the first account contains the emotion within a sentence that ends it. By contrast, the unspoken anger in the second account acquires a sustained life in the tree metaphor. To sun something with smiles is to make a sign of friendliness into a means of feeding a threat. The possessive garden and the contrasting stealth of the foe then make responsibility contestable: the enemy enters, but enters an environment prepared by the person telling the story. The final tableau invites readers to judge the speaker precisely where the controlled lyric offers no signal of repentance.

↑ Back to contents

Textual Conversations: outrage and revenge

Janina has a grievance that a reader need not equate with the lyric speaker’s quarrel. The useful comparison is the passage from anger to secret action and the control each speaker has over what readers know, not a claim that both motives are identical.

↑ Back to contents

HSC practice

At what point is anger deliberately cultivated rather than merely repressed? Analyse a structural transition and then contrast Blake’s openly narrated cultivation with Tokarczuk’s delayed disclosure.

↑ Back to contents